Castro says that his economic model is not working too well. He confessed this to an astounded journalist who probed deeper. Castro clarified further that the government took up too big a role. (Trudeau - what did you think when you were swimming in his pool as a guest?)
Business owners definitely need to feel that they are in an exciting economy, not squeezed out by government. Sometimes Canada can slide over to the Castro approach and the UK has been at it for decades, forcing my parents to immigrate.
Although everyone thinks of the UK as Europe's free market laissez-faire poster child, nothing could be further from the truth. Britain is in fact the only major democracy to have flirted with full-scale Soviet communism.
It is often forgotten that after the war the British government confiscated the assets of most of Britain's industrialists. In 1946 the government nationalised the entire coal industry; that was quickly followed by the State confiscation of the railways, the electricity generating companies, all the country's hospitals, the telephone company, the gas companies, the entire iron and steel industry and all the shipbuilding yards. My grandfather was head of one of the ship building unions that crippled the industry and he was always telling us the business would return. It never did and the skills were lost for ever.
And then in a final coup de theatre the bulk of the country's car industry was also brought into State ownership.
No other country in Europe embarked on anything like the scale of Britain's experiment with communism, and none experienced such disastrous results. All of the nationalised industries, without exception, fell into a death spiral of inefficient operations, militant unionism, high costs, poor quality, rubbish customer service, abysmal design, zero innovation and and ever greater reliance on subsidies from the taxpayer and protectionism.
When Margaret Thatcher quite rightly decided to turn off the subsidy tap in the 1980s the industries crumbled. Leftists blame her for destroying British industry but the truth is that it was destroyed by decades of Labour's Clause 4 in action. All Margaret Thatcher did was administer the last rites.
It's an interesting diversion to wonder what might have happened if the great magnates of British industry had been allowed to keep their businesses in the private sector. Would the exposure to competition and the drive for innovation, efficiency and quality that competition necessitates, have taken British industry in a different direction? Would the Brits today have a million more jobs in manufacturing and be recognised as world leaders in some industries? Would Britain still be mass producing Austins, Triumphs, MGs and Rovers?
Worrying trends are appearing in the Obama administration's policy discussions and Canada's too. Business owners are telling me they do not want to move their work to China but how can they compete with cheap Chinese products flooding our country?
No comments:
Post a Comment